The Canopy Filtered Showerhead meets
the Weddell Duo Shower Filter
Best Overall at Who What Wear and the top pick at mindbodygreen, with a filter that cut chlorine 97% in Water Filter Guru's lab test. We tested it head-to-head against the Weddell Duo Shower Filter across 6 key dimensions.
Canopy Filtered Showerhead
“Best Overall at Who What Wear and the top pick at mindbodygreen, with a filter that cut chlorine 97% in Water Filter Guru's lab test”
Weddell Duo Shower Filter
“The top pick at Water Filter Guru and WIRED, NSF/ANSI 177 certified, and the only filter to take chlorine to zero in Water Filter Guru's lab test”
Head-to-Head Breakdown
Strengths & Weaknesses
Canopy Filtered Showerhead
- Cut chlorine 97% in Water Filter Guru's lab test while keeping the strongest flow it measured, 2.33 GPM
- Canopy's shared filter took chloramine water to undetectable total chlorine in WIRED's testing
- Three spray settings and four finishes, and NBC Select called its filter swap the easiest of ten
- Not NSF certified, and Canopy has published no lab data for the filter
- Water Filter Guru found trihalomethane levels went up, not down, after the filter
- mindbodygreen found the head hard to open, and TODAY reports mixed durability reviews
Weddell Duo Shower Filter
- Took chlorine from 1.68 to 0 ppm in Water Filter Guru's test, the only filter of 13 to reach zero
- Certified to NSF/ANSI 177 and listed on NSF's register, which WIRED's top showerhead pick still isn't
- Cartridges are rated for 10,000 gallons, and a refill set costs $24.99
- Cut flow to 1.42 GPM in Water Filter Guru's test, the slowest of the group
- WIRED found it left some total chlorine behind in chloramine-treated water
- The cartridge housing hangs off your shower arm, a look CNN Underscored didn't love
The Verdict
Our Bottom Line
The Weddell Duo and the Canopy finish level at 83.2. The Duo earns its points on chlorine removal, lab verification and upkeep, where its NSF listing, zero-chlorine lab result and 10,000-gallon cartridges lead the group. The Canopy earns the same total on pressure and chloramine. We named the Canopy best overall because it replaces your showerhead with the strongest flow Water Filter Guru measured, and its filter cleared chloramine in WIRED's testing where the Duo left some behind. On chlorinated water, the Duo gives you certified results for $60 less.
Canopy Filtered Showerhead
Sabrina Talbert has used filtered showerheads for two years, and the Canopy is her Best Overall at Who What Wear. mindbodygreen ranks it first in its editor-scored guide, TODAY's shopping team calls it the editor favorite, and NBC Select keeps it among ten picks its editors lived with for at least a month.
- You want a new showerhead and a filter in one purchase
- Your utility treats water with chloramine, which Canopy's filter handled in WIRED's testing
- You care about strong pressure and a choice of spray patterns
- You're fine paying $25 every 90 days for subscription refills
Weddell Duo Shower Filter
Only two of our eight sources put meters on the water, and both put the Weddell Duo first. Water Filter Guru scored it 9.19 out of 10 after it took chlorine from 1.68 ppm to zero and cleared all four disinfection byproducts in the test water, a result none of the other 12 filters matched. WIRED's Matthew Korfhage calls it "the best-tested shower filter, and among the most economical."
- Your city disinfects with chlorine rather than chloramine
- You want NSF certification and a lab-measured zero chlorine result
- You already like your showerhead and don't want to replace it
- You want the lowest running cost, with cartridges that last 5 to 6 months