The Best Mattresses
Verified by
Ryan V. Editor-in-Chief
When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.
The Saatva Classic is the one mattress every publication in our research recommends. All eight of them name it somewhere in their picks, and three put it at the top: Tom's Guide and Good Housekeeping as Best Overall, and Wirecutter as its top innerspring pick. Tom's Guide has now crowned it Best Mattress of the Year five years running and calls it the highest-scoring mattress it has tested, out of more than 140.


The lab numbers explain why. Tom's Guide scored it 5 out of 5 for pressure relief, temperature regulation and edge support, and Mattress Clarity's 4.6 overall puts it level with the best beds in a field of more than 500. Inside, a queen stacks 884 pocketed coils on top of 416 support coils, with a lumbar zone in the middle and a 3-inch Euro pillow top above. You sleep on the mattress rather than in it, and Good Housekeeping found the firm perimeter makes getting in and out of bed easier.
The buying experience is unusually complete. You choose from three firmness levels and two heights, and Saatva sends a crew to set it up in your room for free. A 365-night trial and a lifetime warranty back it up.
What It Won't Do
Motion isolation is where the coils give the game away. Mattress Clarity scored it 2.7 out of 5, Fortune 3 out of 5, and Wirecutter and Sleep Foundation both say it doesn't isolate much motion, so a partner who tosses and turns will wake you. AARP's cooling test also measured it 26F above baseline, a poor result that clashes with Tom's Guide's perfect temperature score. And the trial is not quite free: Saatva charges a $99 processing fee if you send it back.
The DreamCloud Classic Hybrid is what most of these test teams reach for when the budget is tight. Fortune named it Best Value and Mattress Clarity made it Best Affordable Mattress. Tom's Guide's testers described it as the 'most bang for your buck' and gave it a 5 out of 5 value score. AARP's testers, all 50 or older, rated it 9.8 out of 10 and named it Best Firm.


Its lab scores stand up to beds priced well over $2,000. Mattress Clarity gave it 4.6 out of 5 overall, the same as the Saatva Classic, with 4.4 for both pressure relief and edge support. Tom's Guide found 'good lower back support' from a queen's 792 wrapped coils, and the CloudQuilt cover helped it score 4 out of 5 for cooling in three separate tests.
The $699 list price for a queen is less than a third of the Saatva's $2,229, and DreamCloud still matches the premium brands on terms: a 365-night trial, free returns and a Forever Warranty.
What It Won't Do
Couples are the ones who feel the savings. Tom's Guide called motion isolation 'the weak point', scoring it 3.5 out of 5, so you feel more of a partner's movement than on an all-foam bed. Firmness is the other caution. Tom's Guide rated it 6 out of 10, Mattress Clarity 7.5 and Fortune 8, and Fortune warns it may be too firm for people under 130 pounds. With only one firmness on offer, a lightweight side sleeper has nowhere softer to go. It also arrives compressed in a box, so the setup is on you.
Who Should Buy Which
Saatva Classic
Tom's Guide's highest-scoring mattress and Good Housekeeping's Best Overall, a coil-on-coil innerspring that all eight of our sources recommend
- Your main sleeping position is on your back, or you roll between positions
- You like the bounce of a traditional innerspring
- You sit on the edge of the bed to dress and want it to stay firm
- You want the bed carried in and set up for you
- You want to choose between soft, luxury firm and firm
DreamCloud Classic Hybrid
Fortune's Best Value and Tom's Guide's mid-range pick, a 12-inch hybrid that earned 5/5 for value in lab testing
- You want a supportive hybrid for $699
- You like a firmer feel and spend most of the night on your back
- You are setting up a spare room or a first apartment
- You want a year-long trial and free returns
- You sleep alone or with a partner who doesn't move much