The Best Cast Iron Skillets
Verified by
Ryan V. Editor-in-Chief
When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.
The Smithey Ironware No. 12 wins because it delivers the vintage cast iron experience without the vintage hunt. Prudent Reviews ran every pan across a high-powered induction burner and a battery of egg and searing tests, and ranked the Smithey's machined interior the smoothest of any cast iron they tried. The Barbecue Lab pushed that further by cooking an over-medium egg with butter until the surface behaved like a skating rink, then cooking and releasing an egg with no oil or butter at all.
That smoothness sits on top of genuinely excellent cooking. Prudent Reviews measured the best heat retention in the group and watched the pan stay perfectly flat, with no buzzing or clicking, on a burner powerful enough to make lesser pans warp. The Barbecue Lab confirmed the thermal mass holds heat for high-heat searing, and Uncle Scott's Kitchen found it bakes cornbread as cleanly as any pan in the test.
The design details seal it. Prudent Reviews singled out the slimmer, more comfortable handle and the extra-wide pour spouts as the most refined in the category. You pay for all of this, but you get a pan that behaves like a broken-in heirloom on day one.
What It Won't Do
It is heavy and slow. The Barbecue Lab measured the No. 12 at roughly 8.5 pounds empty and treats the helper handle as mandatory once the pan is full. Both The Barbecue Lab and Prudent Reviews also note the dense body takes real time to come up to temperature, so you preheat with patience. And at $220, or $300 for the griddle-lid combo, it costs about eight times what a Lodge Classic does.
The Lodge Classic 10.25-inch is the value pick because reviewers keep proving that it cooks like pans costing five times more. In a direct cornbread clash, Uncle Scott's Kitchen found the $25 Lodge produced a crust and release identical to the premium Smithey. Kitchen Truth got a crust the color of an old penny that slid straight onto the cutting board.
What separates it from the truly cheap pans is iron mass. Kitchen Truth weighed a Walmart house-brand skillet against the Lodge and found the Lodge carried over a pound more iron, which is why it heats evenly instead of leaving raw hot spots. On induction, Prudent Reviews saw it stay flat and silent, matching the Smithey.
Then there is the math. Kitchen Truth points out a Lodge will last 40 to 100 years on a reliable lifetime warranty, which drives its cost per year toward zero. For most kitchens, that is all the skillet you ever need.
What It Won't Do
The surface is rough. PapaMau compares a brand-new Lodge to a cheese grater, and while Kitchen Truth reframes that texture as a leather strop that grips seasoning well, it lacks the glass-like feel of the Smithey until you build up years of seasoning. It is also heavy for its size with a short handle, and like all thick cast iron it is slow to preheat.
Who Should Buy Which
Smithey Ironware No. 12
A machined, glass-smooth cooking surface that cooks eggs with no oil straight out of the box
- Serious home cooks who want vintage smoothness without hunting the antique market
- Anyone who cooks eggs and delicate foods and wants nonstick behavior on day one
- Induction users who want a silent, warp-free pan
- High-heat searing and large-batch baking fans with the strength to handle 8.5 pounds
- Buyers who see a skillet as a lifelong, heirloom-grade investment
Lodge Classic 10.25-inch
The pan that bakes cornbread every bit as well as skillets costing five times as much
- Budget-conscious cooks who want unbeatable performance per dollar
- First-time cast iron owners building a durable daily workhorse
- Traditionalists happy to develop their own seasoning over time
- Outdoor and campfire cooks who do not want to risk an expensive pan
- Anyone on gas, electric, or induction who wants one skillet that lasts generations