Skip to main content

The Best Vegan Butter

Two picks. Zero regrets.™
We do the homework so you don't have to. 9 expert reviews analyzed, simplified to just two picks: the best overall and the best value.
Vegan Butter
The 28 top products compared
Updated November 12, 2026

Verified by Ryan V. Ryan V. Editor-in-Chief

When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Meet the winners
Best Overall
.
Country Crock Plant Butter with Olive Oil sticks box, front view
SIMPLYTHEBEST 2026 THE BEST.
Country Crock Plant Butter with Olive Oil
"Sporked's 10/10 Best of the Best, sold as four measured sticks for baking"
Best Value
.
Earth Balance Original Buttery Spread 15 oz tub, front label with orange lid, on white
SIMPLYTHEBEST 2026 BEST VALUE.
Earth Balance Original Buttery Spread
"VegNews readers' 2026 pick for best vegan butter, in a 15-ounce tub"
Why the Country Crock Plant Butter with Olive Oil is The Best

Country Crock Plant Butter with Olive Oil scored a perfect 10 in Sporked's June 2025 tasting, where Danny Palumbo and Ariana Losch named it Best of the Best after trying seven vegan butters plain and on plain and toasted bread. They found it salty, spreadable and rich, with a deep olive flavor.

It bakes well too. Thank You Berry Much ran nine butters through identical chocolate chip cookies and vanilla cupcakes, and Country Crock's olive oil sticks scored 4.0 out of 5 for third place, holding their structure in buttercream. Sarah's Vegan Kitchen also names Country Crock sticks as its affordable, easy-to-find baking butter.

Our previous top pick, Miyoko's European Style, now sits among the runners-up. Its new owner recalled one lot in September 2026 over possible yeast, mold and E. coli contamination, after months of patchy supply. Country Crock comes as four measured sticks at nearly every grocer, which makes it the safer recommendation today.

What It Won't Do

It is salty and soft. Thank You Berry Much called it very salty and found its cookies baked pale, and Tasting Table's 2023 ranking put it 10th of 12, comparing it to light mayo. The oil blend leans on palm, with 5 grams of saturated fat per tablespoon, and the label lists soy. Amazon also sells it only by the case right now, so most people will buy it at the supermarket.

Why the Earth Balance Original Buttery Spread is the Best Value

Earth Balance Original Buttery Spread won VegNews readers' 2026 vote for best vegan butter, and the editors called it the spread that never lets you down in a tumultuous year for the category. Make It Dairy Free tied it for first on toast for its smooth, subtle taste.

The 15-ounce tub is the easiest vegan butter to find, in stock on Amazon and at nearly every grocer. Go Dairy Free's bakers found it the closest to dairy butter in a shortbread test, and The Nutrition Insider's dietitian named it the most affordable option she tried.

Use it for toast, vegetables and mashed potatoes. For serious baking, Country Crock's sticks measure more accurately.

What It Won't Do

Tasting Table found it noticeably salty, and the oil blend includes palm and soybean oils, so it contains soy. In Thank You Berry Much's bake-off the tub scored 3.5 out of 5 and made greasier cookies, and Go Dairy Free's shortbread went stale within a few days.

How They Compare

Country Crock Earth Balance
Taste Best +10
90
80
Cooking Best +12
88
76
Texture Value +6
80
86
Availability Value +10
84
94
Trust Best +4
88
84
Ingredients Best +2
64
62
Best Overall
85
Country Crock
Best Value
80
Earth Balance

The Competition

#3 Country Crock Plant Butter with Avocado Oil

Sporked's Best Dairy Dupe at 9.5 out of 10, with a bolder, lingering buttery tang, and Make It Dairy Free's overall pick. Same palm-based sticks as our winner, with avocado oil in place of olive.

Check Price
#4 Earth Balance Vegan Buttery Sticks

VegNews calls these the go-to for professional vegan bakers, and Thank You Berry Much scored them 3.75 out of 5 for reliable, golden bakes. Its tester noticed a slight new tang.

Check Price
#5 Miyoko's Creamery Organic Oat Milk Butter

Sporked's Best Creamy at 9 out of 10 and The Nutrition Insider's best spreadable butter. Nut-free and palm-free, but it comes in a tub that is not meant for baking.

Check Price
#6 Miyoko's Creamery European Style Cultured Vegan Butter

The best-tasting cultured butter at Tasting Table and The Nutrition Insider, and second in VegNews readers' 2026 vote. Its new owner recalled one lot in September 2026 over possible yeast, mold and E. coli, and supply is still patchy.

Check Price

Who Should Buy Which

BEST OVERALL
Country Crock Plant Butter with Olive Oil

Country Crock Plant Butter with Olive Oil

Sporked's 10/10 Best of the Best, sold as four measured sticks for baking

  • You bake cookies, cakes or frosting
  • You want measured sticks that swap one-for-one with dairy butter
  • You like a rich, salty flavor on toast
  • You want a vegan butter sold at almost every grocer
BEST VALUE
Earth Balance Original Buttery Spread

Earth Balance Original Buttery Spread

VegNews readers' 2026 pick for best vegan butter, in a 15-ounce tub

  • You mainly spread butter on toast or vegetables
  • You want the easiest vegan butter to order online
  • You are buying for a crowd on a budget
  • You do not need a soy-free option
See head-to-head comparison →

How We Decided

28
Products
9
Reviews
2
Winners
Scoring Weights
30%
25%
15%
10%
10%
10%
Taste
Cooking
Texture
Availability
Trust
Ingredients
Sources Analyzed
SporkedThank You Berry MuchVegNewsTasting TableThe Nutrition InsiderSarah's Vegan KitchenMake It Dairy Free + 1 more
Read our full methodology
Menu