Skip to main content
Vegan Butter · Comparison

The Country Crock Plant Butter with Olive Oil meets
the Earth Balance Original Buttery Spread

Sporked's 10/10 Best of the Best, sold as four measured sticks for baking. We tested it head-to-head against the Earth Balance Original Buttery Spread across 6 key dimensions.

Country Crock Plant Butter with Olive Oil sticks box, front view
BEST

Country Crock Plant Butter with Olive Oil

“Sporked's 10/10 Best of the Best, sold as four measured sticks for baking”

Our Score
84.6 / 100
Earth Balance Original Buttery Spread 15 oz tub, front label with orange lid, on white
VALUE

Earth Balance Original Buttery Spread

“VegNews readers' 2026 pick for best vegan butter, in a 15-ounce tub”

Our Score
79.9 / 100
01

Head-to-Head Breakdown

Taste
30% of score +
Country Crock
90
Earth Balance
80
Country Crock Plant Butter with Olive Oil

Sporked's Danny Palumbo and Ariana Losch scored it 10 out of 10, finding it salty, spreadable and rich with a deep olive flavor. Tasting Table's 2023 ranking put it 10th of 12.

Earth Balance Original Buttery Spread

Make It Dairy Free tied it for first on toast for its smooth, subtle taste. Tasting Table ranked it fifth of 12, rich and creamy but noticeably salty.

Cooking
25% of score +
Country Crock
88
Earth Balance
76
Country Crock Plant Butter with Olive Oil

Third of nine in Thank You Berry Much's 2026 cookie and cupcake bake-off at 4.0 out of 5, holding structure well in buttercream. Sarah's Vegan Kitchen picks Country Crock sticks for affordable baking.

Earth Balance Original Buttery Spread

Go Dairy Free found it the closest to dairy butter in shortbread, though the cookies went stale quickly. Thank You Berry Much scored the tub 3.5 out of 5, with greasier cookies.

Texture
15% of score +
Country Crock
80
Earth Balance
86
Country Crock Plant Butter with Olive Oil

Sporked found it spreadable on plain and toasted bread. Sarah's Vegan Kitchen notes the sticks run softer than dairy butter.

Earth Balance Original Buttery Spread

A soft tub spread that goes straight from the fridge onto toast.

Availability
10% of score +
Country Crock
84
Earth Balance
94
Country Crock Plant Butter with Olive Oil

Stocked by Walmart, Target, Kroger and most US grocers. Amazon currently lists only a 12-pack case.

Earth Balance Original Buttery Spread

In stock on Amazon and sold by nearly every US grocer.

Trust
10% of score +
Country Crock
88
Earth Balance
84
Country Crock Plant Butter with Olive Oil

Country Crock placed third in VegNews readers' 2026 vote, and its plant butters place well in tests from 2020 to 2026.

Earth Balance Original Buttery Spread

VegNews readers voted it 2026's best vegan butter, and the editors called it the reliable pick in a tumultuous year.

Ingredients
10% of score +
Country Crock
64
Earth Balance
62
Country Crock Plant Butter with Olive Oil

Palm fruit, palm kernel, canola and olive oils with 5 g saturated fat and 110 mg sodium per tablespoon. Contains soy.

Earth Balance Original Buttery Spread

Palm, canola, soybean, flax and olive oils with 3 g saturated fat and 105 mg sodium per tablespoon. Contains soy.

02

Strengths & Weaknesses

Country Crock Plant Butter with Olive Oil

+ Strengths
  • Sporked's Best of the Best at 10 out of 10, rich with a deep olive flavor
  • Third of nine in Thank You Berry Much's 2026 bake-off, and it held its shape in buttercream
  • Sarah's Vegan Kitchen picks Country Crock sticks as its affordable baking butter
− Weaknesses
  • Tasting Table ranked it 10th of 12, calling it oily and waxy
  • Very salty, and cookies baked pale in Thank You Berry Much's test
  • Palm oil blend with 5 g saturated fat per tablespoon
Key flaw: It is salty and soft.

Earth Balance Original Buttery Spread

+ Strengths
  • Won VegNews readers' 2026 vote for best vegan butter
  • Make It Dairy Free tied it for first, praising its smooth, subtle taste
  • Go Dairy Free's bakers found it the closest to dairy butter in shortbread
− Weaknesses
  • Tasting Table found it noticeably salty
  • Contains soy and palm oil
  • Thank You Berry Much's cookies came out greasier than with stick butters
Key flaw: Tasting Table found it noticeably salty, and the oil blend includes palm and soybean oils, so it contains soy.
03

The Verdict

Our Bottom Line

Country Crock Plant Butter with Olive Oil scored a perfect 10 in Sporked's June 2025 tasting, where Danny Palumbo and Ariana Losch named it Best of the Best after trying seven vegan butters plain and on plain and toasted bread. They found it salty, spreadable and rich, with a deep olive flavor.

BEST
Country Crock Plant Butter with Olive Oil
Country Crock Plant Butter with Olive Oil sticks box, front view

Country Crock Plant Butter with Olive Oil scored a perfect 10 in Sporked's June 2025 tasting, where Danny Palumbo and Ariana Losch named it Best of the Best after trying seven vegan butters plain and on plain and toasted bread. They found it salty, spreadable and rich, with a deep olive flavor.

Best for:
  • You bake cookies, cakes or frosting
  • You want measured sticks that swap one-for-one with dairy butter
  • You like a rich, salty flavor on toast
  • You want a vegan butter sold at almost every grocer
VALUE
Earth Balance Original Buttery Spread
Earth Balance Original Buttery Spread 15 oz tub, front label with orange lid, on white

Earth Balance Original Buttery Spread won VegNews readers' 2026 vote for best vegan butter, and the editors called it the spread that never lets you down in a tumultuous year for the category. Make It Dairy Free tied it for first on toast for its smooth, subtle taste.

Best for:
  • You mainly spread butter on toast or vegetables
  • You want the easiest vegan butter to order online
  • You are buying for a crowd on a budget
  • You do not need a soy-free option
04

Specifications

Spec Country Crock Plant Butter with Olive Oil Earth Balance Original Buttery Spread
Base Palm Fruit, Canola & Olive Oil Blend Palm, Canola, Soybean, Flax & Olive Oils
Format Sticks (4 ct, 16 oz) Tub (15 oz)
Size 16 oz 15 oz
Organic No No
Palm Oil Free No No
Allergens Soy Soy
Read the full Vegan Butter review
Menu