The GE Profile Opal 2.0 keeps winning these roundups for a straightforward reason: nobody else makes nugget ice this good at home. Reviewed.com's Jonathan Chan, who runs ice makers through repeatable lab tests measuring batch timing, ice consistency, and noise levels, called the Opal's output 'crisp and clean-tasting.' CNN Underscored's Michelle Rae Uy, testing eight machines side by side, placed the Opal 2.0 XL as her top large-capacity pick. Food Network's Taylor Murray, after grinding through 13 models, ranked it Best Splurge.


The 1-gallon detachable side tank is the feature that separates the Opal from every competitor we evaluated. Most countertop ice makers have small reservoirs that need constant babysitting. The Opal's tank sits on the side, holds a full gallon, and pops off for sink refills. That single design choice means you can leave it running through a dinner party without checking every 30 minutes.
Smart features push it further ahead. WiFi connectivity, Alexa and Google Home voice control, and a companion app that handles scheduling and cleaning reminders. Popular Science's Brandt Ranj specifically highlighted the smart suite as best-in-class. For a machine that sits on your counter year-round, app-based maintenance scheduling is more practical than it sounds.
The Opal produces 24 lbs of nugget ice daily. That sounds modest next to the GoveeLife's 60 lbs, but most households never need that volume. 24 lbs fills roughly 50 glasses worth of ice per day, plenty for a family of four that hosts occasionally.
What It Won't Do
At $419, the Opal costs three times what the Chefman Iceman runs. It weighs 44 pounds and spans 17.5 inches wide, eating serious counter real estate. And the 10-minute wait for your first batch feels slow when the Chefman drops ice in 6 minutes flat. If you just need cold drinks and don't care about nugget texture, you are paying a steep premium for chewability.
Food Network's Taylor Murray tested 13 countertop ice makers over weeks of batch timing, hourly yield weighing, and taste testing. The Chefman Iceman Dual-Size won Best Overall in that group, producing its first ice cubes in just six minutes, the fastest of any machine she tested. At $130, it undercuts the GE Profile Opal by nearly $300.
Murray measured 1 pound 4 ounces of ice in the first hour, a strong sustained output that keeps up with party demand. The two-size bullet ice option (small for everyday drinks, large for cocktails that need slower melting) adds flexibility that single-size machines lack. The controls are three buttons: power, size, and self-clean. Nothing to figure out, nothing to break.
The built-in handle is worth mentioning because most ice makers that claim portability weigh 30+ pounds and have no grip. The Chefman weighs 17.5 pounds. You can actually carry it to the patio, RV, or garage with one hand. That makes it a genuine dual-purpose machine: countertop staple and portable party companion.
For $130, you get the fastest ice production, two size options, self-cleaning, and real portability. Nothing else in this price range combines all four.
What It Won't Do
Bullet ice is not nugget ice. If you want that Sonic-style chewable texture, the Chefman will disappoint. It has zero smart features: no app, no WiFi, no voice control. And Food Network's Taylor Murray noted some cycles get audibly noisy, which matters if the machine runs in an open-plan kitchen.
Who Should Buy Which
GE Profile Opal 2.0 Countertop Nugget Ice Maker
The nugget ice standard that four review teams keep crowning
- Nugget ice enthusiasts who want the Sonic/Chick-fil-A texture at home
- Smart home households already using Alexa or Google Home for kitchen appliances
- Frequent entertainers who need hands-off ice production with app monitoring
- Buyers who plan to use the machine daily year-round and value long-term build quality
- Anyone tired of refilling small reservoirs, the 1-gallon side tank solves this
Iceman by Chefman Dual-Size Countertop Ice Maker
Fastest ice in Food Network's 13-model test at half the premium price
- Budget-conscious buyers who want fast ice without spending $400+
- RV owners, tailgaters, or patio users who need a genuinely portable unit
- Households that just need cold drinks and don't care about ice shape trends
- Small kitchens where a 17.5-inch-wide premium machine won't fit
- First-time ice maker buyers testing whether they'll use the machine enough to justify an upgrade later