The Best Toasters
Verified by
Hadleigh V. Lead Product Analyst
When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.
Reviewed, Serious Eats and Food & Wine all name the Breville Die-Cast 2-Slice Smart Toaster their best toaster. Food & Wine ran 47 pop-up toasters through several rounds, and its notes dubbed this one "the Rolls-Royce of toasters." RTINGS, which has tested more than 30, gives its top spot to the 4-slice version of the same design.


Start with the toast. Serious Eats found it browned bread quickly and evenly, toasted bagels without burning, and turned out pleasantly chewy frozen waffles. On the medium setting Food & Wine's testers saw both sides of each slice match, and it won two of their test rounds.
Then there's the motorized carriage. Press Toast and it lowers the bread for you, then raises it when the cycle ends. Lift & Look brings the bread up mid-cycle so you can check the color without cancelling, and A Bit More adds a short burst when a slice comes up light. Bagel and Frozen buttons adjust the cycle for each. Breville lists it at $199.95.
What It Won't Do
At $199.95 it costs far more than most pop-up toasters, a point Reviewed's Sharon Franke makes directly. The slots take sandwich bread and bagels but not larger products, and Serious Eats found sourdough came out underdone on top. Food & Wine noticed it was more consistent on medium than at the extra-light and extra-dark ends. The listed warranty is 1 year, against 3 years on the Cuisinart.
The Cuisinart 4-Slice Custom Select costs half what the Zwilling does, and in a blind toast test, most people wouldn't taste the difference. TrustRanker said it 'out toasts half the fancy models on the market,' and Best Product Quest confirmed its heat distribution is nearly as even as toasters twice the price.


What separates the Cuisinart from other budget options is the Bread Select Dial. Best Product Quest verified that the dial changes the heating cycle's time and temperature profile depending on whether you're toasting waffles, English muffins, pastries, or standard bread. The single-slice mode is another rare feature at this price, ensuring even results when you only need one piece.
TrustRanker called the build 'like a tank,' and the lever has a satisfying mechanical heft that belies the $80 price tag. The 3-year Cuisinart warranty adds security. For a family that goes through four slices every morning, it handles the whole batch in one cycle.
What It Won't Do
The browning control knob has no clicks or detents. You turn it by feel and hope you hit the same spot as yesterday. TrustRanker flagged this as the primary annoyance. The push-down lever is stiff, the crumb trays are fiddly to remove, and TrustRanker noted it 'isn't winning any beauty contest.' If counter looks matter to you, the Smeg is the better-looking choice.
Who Should Buy Which
Breville Die-Cast 2-Slice Smart Toaster
The top toaster at Reviewed, Serious Eats and Food & Wine, with a motorized carriage that lowers and lifts the bread for you
- You toast two slices most mornings and want the same shade every time
- Bagel and frozen waffle regulars who will use the dedicated buttons
- You like checking progress without cancelling the cycle
- Small households with limited counter space
- You want a metal toaster built to sit out on the counter for years
Cuisinart 4-Slice Custom Select Toaster
Serious Eats' best four-slice toaster, from the same Custom Select line Good Housekeeping ranks first
- Families who toast four slices at once
- You want presets for bagels, English muffins and waffles for under $100
- You often toast a single slice
- Buyers who value a 3-year warranty
- You don't need a motorized lift