The Best Stationary Bikes
Verified by
Ryan V. Editor-in-Chief
When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.
The NordicTrack X24 Bike is the Best Overall pick at Garage Gym Reviews, Fortune and BarBend, the three largest hands-on bike tests in our research. Garage Gym Reviews has tested more than 50 exercise bikes and gave the X24 its Gold pick at 4.6 out of 5. Treadmill Review Guru named it its best smart bike at 89.


Incline is what makes it different. The frame tilts from -10% to +20%, which BarBend called possibly the largest incline range it has seen on an indoor cycle. On iFIT rides, SmartAdjust moves that incline and the 24 resistance levels for you, so a climb on screen becomes a climb under your legs. The 24-inch touchscreen pivots off the bike for strength sessions, and two-sided pedals take SPD cleats or ordinary sneakers.
Every guide that rated both bikes put the X24 ahead of a Peloton: 4.6 to 4.3 at Garage Gym Reviews, 4.5 to 4.0 against the Bike+ at Fortune, 4.3 to 4.2 at BarBend, and 89 to 84 at Treadmill Review Guru. NordicTrack lists it at $2,799.99 and was selling it for $1,499.99 during our research.
What It Won't Do
Plan its spot before it arrives. The X24 weighs 205 pounds, and Garage Gym Reviews and BarBend both count that against it. Fortune's tester found the incline adjustments choppy and unpredictable. The features that justify the price, from SmartAdjust to trainer-led rides, need iFIT Pro at $39 a month once the included month ends. Without it you can still ride and change incline from the handlebars.
When our sources want a Peloton-style ride without Peloton pricing, they point to the Schwinn IC4. BarBend named it the best bike for beginners at 4.3 out of 5, and its tester said it "seriously reminds me of the Peloton Bike, but at half the cost." Treadmill Review Guru made it its best affordable bike at 84, and Live Science picked it as its best bike for resistance.


It runs 100 levels of magnetic resistance on a quiet belt drive and supports riders up to 330 pounds. Dual-sided pedals take SPD cleats or sneakers. In place of a built-in screen you get a backlit console and a tablet holder, and the bike pairs over Bluetooth with the Peloton app, Zwift or Schwinn's optional JRNY. You choose the subscription, or skip it.
Schwinn lists the IC4 at $999, $1,800 below the X24's list price, and covers the frame for 10 years.
What It Won't Do
You supply the screen. BarBend's main complaint is that the IC4 has no display for streaming, and Treadmill Review Guru calls it simpler than some cyclists want. It has no incline and no automatic resistance, so app classes depend on you turning the knob. Live Science found Schwinn's own JRNY app thin on content, which pushes most owners toward the Peloton app or Zwift and their monthly fees.
Who Should Buy Which
NordicTrack X24 Bike
The Best Overall pick at Garage Gym Reviews, Fortune and BarBend, with a frame that tilts from -10% to +20%
- Riders who want hills that actually tilt the bike
- iFIT members, or anyone who wants a trainer to control resistance
- Households with riders up to 350 pounds
- You have a permanent spot for a 205-pound bike
- You want to ride in sneakers or SPD cleats
Schwinn IC4
A Peloton-style ride for $999 that works with the Peloton app, Zwift or no subscription at all
- Peloton app subscribers who don't want Peloton hardware
- Zwift riders who want a quiet spin bike
- Beginners building a cycling habit for under $1,000
- You already own a tablet to stream classes
- Riders up to 330 pounds