Skip to main content
Stationary Bikes · Comparison

The NordicTrack X24 Bike meets
the Schwinn IC4

The Best Overall pick at Garage Gym Reviews, Fortune and BarBend, with a frame that tilts from -10% to +20%. We tested it head-to-head against the Schwinn IC4 across 6 key dimensions.

NordicTrack X24 Bike three-quarter front view on white, showing the 24-inch pivoting touchscreen, handlebars, saddle, flywheel and incline base
BEST

NordicTrack X24 Bike

“The Best Overall pick at Garage Gym Reviews, Fortune and BarBend, with a frame that tilts from -10% to +20%”

$2,799.99MSRP
Our Score
86.4 / 100
Schwinn IC4 indoor cycling bike in gray with red accents, front three-quarter view on white, showing the console, media holder, dumbbell cradles, flywheel and dual-sided pedals
VALUE

Schwinn IC4

“A Peloton-style ride for $999 that works with the Peloton app, Zwift or no subscription at all”

$999MSRP
Our Score
76.7 / 100
01

Head-to-Head Breakdown

Ride
25% of score +
NordicTrack
88
Schwinn
82
NordicTrack X24 Bike

Incline runs from -10% to +20% with 24 magnetic resistance levels, and SmartAdjust changes both during iFIT rides, which Garage Gym Reviews calls convenient. BarBend says it may be the largest incline range it has seen on an indoor cycle. Fortune's tester found the incline changes choppy and unpredictable.

Schwinn IC4

100 levels of magnetic resistance on a belt drive. BarBend's tester said it "seriously reminds me of the Peloton Bike, but at half the cost," and Live Science named it its best bike for resistance.

Build
20% of score +
NordicTrack
90
Schwinn
80
NordicTrack X24 Bike

A 205-pound frame rated for riders up to 350 pounds. NordicTrack covers the frame for 10 years, which Fortune lists as a highlight, though the weight makes it hard to move.

Schwinn IC4

Rated for riders up to 330 pounds with a 10-year frame warranty. Treadmill Review Guru scored it 84 out of 100.

Software
20% of score +
NordicTrack
92
Schwinn
62
NordicTrack X24 Bike

A 24-inch pivoting touchscreen running iFIT, with trainer-led rides that adjust the bike for you. Treadmill Review Guru named it its best smart bike at 89 out of 100. iFIT Pro costs $39 a month after the included first month.

Schwinn IC4

There is no screen, only a backlit console and a tablet holder, and BarBend's tester missed having one for streaming. It connects to the Peloton app, Zwift and JRNY, though Live Science found JRNY's content limited.

Comfort
15% of score +
NordicTrack
80
Schwinn
75
NordicTrack X24 Bike

Two-sided pedals take SPD cleats or ordinary sneakers in the toe cages, so cycling shoes are optional. None of our guides raised fit complaints.

Schwinn IC4

Riders can clip in with SPD cleats or use sneakers in the toe cages, and fit drew no complaints in our sources.

Noise
10% of score +
NordicTrack
75
Schwinn
85
NordicTrack X24 Bike

NordicTrack's magnetic resistance has no friction pads to wear or squeal. No guide took a noise reading.

Schwinn IC4

Magnetic resistance on a belt drive, and none of our sources reported noise trouble.

Trust
10% of score +
NordicTrack
85
Schwinn
80
NordicTrack X24 Bike

NordicTrack covers the frame for 10 years with 2 years on parts and 1 year on labor. Four of our eight guides rank it first or name it their top smart bike.

Schwinn IC4

Schwinn covers the frame for 10 years and parts for 3. BarBend, Treadmill Review Guru and Live Science all recommend it.

02

Strengths & Weaknesses

NordicTrack X24 Bike

+ Strengths
  • Best Overall at Garage Gym Reviews (Gold pick, 4.6 out of 5), Fortune (4.5) and BarBend (4.3)
  • Incline from -10% to +20%, which BarBend calls possibly the largest range it has seen on an indoor cycle
  • SmartAdjust moves resistance and incline during iFIT rides on a 24-inch pivoting touchscreen
− Weaknesses
  • Weighs 205 pounds, a drawback both Garage Gym Reviews and BarBend list
  • Fortune's tester found the incline adjustments choppy and unpredictable
  • SmartAdjust and the classes need iFIT Pro at $39 a month after the first month
Key flaw: Plan its spot before it arrives.

Schwinn IC4

+ Strengths
  • BarBend's Best for Beginners at 4.3 out of 5 and Treadmill Review Guru's Best Affordable bike at 84
  • BarBend's tester said it "seriously reminds me of the Peloton Bike, but at half the cost"
  • Pairs over Bluetooth with Peloton, Zwift or Schwinn's optional JRNY app
− Weaknesses
  • No screen for streaming, BarBend's main complaint
  • No incline and no automatic resistance, so app classes rely on you turning the knob
  • Live Science found Schwinn's JRNY app limited on content
Key flaw: You supply the screen.
03

The Verdict

Our Bottom Line

The NordicTrack X24 Bike is the Best Overall pick at Garage Gym Reviews, Fortune and BarBend, the three largest hands-on bike tests in our research. Garage Gym Reviews has tested more than 50 exercise bikes and gave the X24 its Gold pick at 4.6 out of 5. Treadmill Review Guru named it its best smart bike at 89.

BEST
NordicTrack X24 Bike
NordicTrack X24 Bike three-quarter front view on white, showing the 24-inch pivoting touchscreen, handlebars, saddle, flywheel and incline base

The NordicTrack X24 Bike is the Best Overall pick at Garage Gym Reviews, Fortune and BarBend, the three largest hands-on bike tests in our research. Garage Gym Reviews has tested more than 50 exercise bikes and gave the X24 its Gold pick at 4.6 out of 5. Treadmill Review Guru named it its best smart bike at 89.

Best for:
  • Riders who want hills that actually tilt the bike
  • iFIT members, or anyone who wants a trainer to control resistance
  • Households with riders up to 350 pounds
  • You have a permanent spot for a 205-pound bike
  • You want to ride in sneakers or SPD cleats
VALUE
Schwinn IC4
Schwinn IC4 indoor cycling bike in gray with red accents, front three-quarter view on white, showing the console, media holder, dumbbell cradles, flywheel and dual-sided pedals

When our sources want a Peloton-style ride without Peloton pricing, they point to the Schwinn IC4. BarBend named it the best bike for beginners at 4.3 out of 5, and its tester said it "seriously reminds me of the Peloton Bike, but at half the cost." Treadmill Review Guru made it its best affordable bike at 84, and Live Science picked it as its best bike for resistance.

Best for:
  • Peloton app subscribers who don't want Peloton hardware
  • Zwift riders who want a quiet spin bike
  • Beginners building a cycling habit for under $1,000
  • You already own a tablet to stream classes
  • Riders up to 330 pounds
04

Specifications

Spec NordicTrack X24 Bike Schwinn IC4
Resistance Magnetic, 24 levels Magnetic, 100 levels
Screen 24 in touchscreen LCD + tablet holder
Incline -10% to +20% None
Max Rider 350 lbs 330 lbs
Bike Weight 205 lbs 114 lbs
Pedals SPD or toe cage SPD or toe cage
Subscription iFIT Pro, $39/mo Optional (JRNY, Peloton app, Zwift)
Warranty 10-yr frame, 2-yr parts 10-yr frame, 3-yr parts
Read the full Stationary Bikes review
Menu