Skip to main content

The Best Impact Drivers

Two picks. Zero regrets.™
We do the homework so you don't have to. 5 expert reviews analyzed, simplified to just two picks: the best overall and the best value.
Impact Drivers
The 39 top products compared
Updated November 17, 2026

Verified by Hadleigh V. Hadleigh V. Lead Product Analyst

When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Meet the winners
Best Overall
.
Milwaukee M18 FUEL 1/4" Hex Impact Driver Gen 4 (2953-20) side profile on white, bare tool with belt clip
SIMPLYTHEBEST 2026 THE BEST.
Milwaukee M18 FUEL 2953-20 (Gen 4)
"Broke a stuck bolt loose faster than any of the 12 drivers Pro Tool Reviews timed, from a 4.47-inch body"
Best Value
.
Ryobi ONE+ HP 18V Brushless 4-Mode Impact Driver PBLID04 bare tool, 3/4 front view on white
SIMPLYTHEBEST 2026 BEST VALUE.
Ryobi ONE+ HP PBLID04B
$129MSRP
"Pro Tool Reviews' Best for the Money: within a second of the Milwaukee on screws for $129"
Why the Milwaukee M18 FUEL 2953-20 (Gen 4) is The Best

Pro Tool Reviews timed 12 impact drivers on the same structural screw, lag screw and stuck bolt, and the Milwaukee M18 FUEL 2953 finished second overall with 94 points. It broke the test bolt loose in 1.64 seconds, the quickest of the twelve, and drove the structural screw in 5.96 seconds, a tenth behind the winning Flex. GearLab ran 144 tests of its own across 12 drivers and named the 2953 its Best Tool-Only pick, with 9.9 for speed and a perfect 10 for torque.

We chose it over the Flex for its size and weight. The head measures 4.47 inches, the shortest here, and Pro Tool Reviews weighed it at 4.6 pounds with a battery against 5.0 for the Flex. Its 2026 follow-up named the Milwaukee the best balance of performance, size and weight. You notice that after an afternoon of overhead decking screws.

The 2,000 in-lb rating looks low next to the 2,500 claimed by Flex and DeWalt. The bolt test shows how little that number tells you: the DeWalt DCF860, rated 25% higher, needed 2.56 seconds to break the same bolt.

What It Won't Do

It costs $179 bare at Home Depot, $50 more than the Ryobi, before you buy an M18 battery. If you aren't on M18 yet, Pro Tool Reviews lists the kit at $319. The Flex also left less of the lag screw standing after 30 seconds (0.63 inches against 1.06), so long structural lags go in a little slower with the Milwaukee.

Why the Ryobi ONE+ HP PBLID04B is the Best Value

Pro Tool Reviews gave the Ryobi PBLID04 its Best for the Money award, and the stopwatch backs that up. It drove the structural screw in 6.80 seconds, a hair quicker than the Ridgid and three-quarters of a second faster than the DeWalt DCF860, which costs $70 more. After 30 seconds on the lag screw it left 1.13 inches standing, almost level with the Milwaukee's 1.06.

It scored 87, seven points behind the Milwaukee, and Ryobi sells it for $129. The 2026 follow-up called it compelling for DIYers and value-conscious pros. With its battery it weighed 3.8 pounds, lighter than every driver in the top three.

If you own a Ryobi drill or leaf blower, you probably have the battery already.

What It Won't Do

At about 5.2 inches it is the longest of Pro Tool Reviews' top four, so it fits between joists less easily than the Milwaukee. Its bolt break was fifth best at 2.03 seconds. Ryobi sells the PBLID04 bare only, with no kit, and the warranty runs 3 years against Milwaukee's 5.

How They Compare

Milwaukee Ryobi
Performance Best +8
94
86
Torque Best +13
95
82
Comfort Best +8
92
84
Trust Best +13
95
82
Size Best +25
95
70
Best Overall
94
Milwaukee
Best Value
82
Ryobi

The Competition

#3 Flex 24V Quick Eject FX1371A

Pro Tool Reviews' Best Overall, fastest on the structural screw at 5.86 seconds and best on the lag at 0.63 inches left. It lost our top spot on weight: 5.0 pounds as tested, the heaviest of the top four.

Check Price
#4 Ridgid 18V Brushless R862312B

Third at Pro Tool Reviews and its 2026 pick for balance of performance and price, at $134 bare. It actually outscored the Ryobi by a point, but it costs more, sells only at Home Depot, and its head is longer than the Milwaukee's. Register it for Ridgid's Lifetime Service Agreement.

Buy Direct
#5 Kobalt XTR 24V KXID 124B-03

GearLab's Best Overall, with perfect 10s for speed, torque and battery life, and a Consumer Reports pick. At 5.56 inches it's the longest here, and Consumer Reports found it extremely noisy. Lowe's only.

Buy Direct
#6 DeWalt DCF860

Our previous Best Overall. It carries the highest torque rating here, yet it finished fifth of 12 at Pro Tool Reviews, which called the result a surprise. At $199 bare it costs more than the faster Milwaukee.

Buy Direct
#7 Hercules 20V Brushless HCB81B
$69.99 MSRP

Our previous Best Value. At $69.99 it scored 80 at Pro Tool Reviews, a point behind the DeWalt DCF860, and broke the bolt fourth fastest. Pro Tool Reviews says its long-term durability is still unproven, and it's sold only at Harbor Freight.

Buy Direct

Who Should Buy Which

BEST OVERALL
Milwaukee M18 FUEL 2953-20 (Gen 4)

Milwaukee M18 FUEL 2953-20 (Gen 4)

Broke a stuck bolt loose faster than any of the 12 drivers Pro Tool Reviews timed, from a 4.47-inch body

  • You drive screws and lags for a living or most weekends
  • You work in tight spaces where a short head matters
  • You already own M18 batteries
  • You want the quickest bolt break of any driver tested
BEST VALUE $129 MSRP
Ryobi ONE+ HP PBLID04B

Ryobi ONE+ HP PBLID04B

Pro Tool Reviews' Best for the Money: within a second of the Milwaukee on screws for $129

  • You already own Ryobi ONE+ batteries
  • You do home projects and want near-pro speed
  • You'd rather keep $50 than shave a second off each screw
  • You shop at Home Depot anyway
See head-to-head comparison →

How We Decided

39
Products
5
Reviews
2
Winners
Scoring Weights
30%
20%
20%
15%
15%
Performance
Torque
Comfort
Trust
Size
Sources Analyzed
Pro Tool ReviewsGearLabConsumer ReportsThis Old HouseBob Vila
Read our full methodology
Menu