The OXO Good Grips 11 lb Stainless Steel Food Scale with Pull-Out Display meets
the Escali Primo Digital Scale
America's Test Kitchen's winner and Serious Eats' best kitchen scale, with a display that slides out from under wide bowls. We tested it head-to-head against the Escali Primo Digital Scale across 6 key dimensions.
OXO Good Grips 11 lb Stainless Steel Food Scale with Pull-Out Display
“America's Test Kitchen's winner and Serious Eats' best kitchen scale, with a display that slides out from under wide bowls”
Escali Primo Digital Scale
“Wirecutter's top kitchen scale since 2017 and Food Network's best overall, accurate across the full range of Serious Eats' tests”
Head-to-Head Breakdown
Strengths & Weaknesses
OXO Good Grips 11 lb Stainless Steel Food Scale with Pull-Out Display
- America's Test Kitchen's winner and Serious Eats' best kitchen scale after Ashlee Redger tested 24 models
- Pull-out display stays readable under mixing bowls and sheet pans that hide other screens
- The Kitchn measured the fastest response of its 10 test scales, and the tray lifts off for washing
- Wirecutter found the newest version consistently inaccurate with small measurements
- Food & Wine saw readings drift a gram or two when bowls sat off-center
- Flour packs in around the display tether and under the platform, per America's Test Kitchen and Food & Wine
Escali Primo Digital Scale
- Wirecutter's top pick since 2017 and Food Network's Best Overall
- Stayed within a gram on every weight in Serious Eats' accuracy range
- Reads in 0.05 oz steps, finer than the OXO's 0.1 oz
- A half-sheet pan hides the display completely, per Serious Eats
- The platform does not lift off, so spills need careful wiping
- No backlight, and America's Test Kitchen wished the screen were bigger
The Verdict
Our Bottom Line
America's Test Kitchen put a dozen scales through lab-certified 30, 200 and 500 gram weights, a 2-inch drop and a tare test with a big bowl of flour. The OXO Good Grips 11 lb won. The testers liked its large, brightly lit digits on a dark background and timed it at about half a second per reading.
OXO Good Grips 11 lb Stainless Steel Food Scale with Pull-Out Display
America's Test Kitchen put a dozen scales through lab-certified 30, 200 and 500 gram weights, a 2-inch drop and a tare test with a big bowl of flour. The OXO Good Grips 11 lb won. The testers liked its large, brightly lit digits on a dark background and timed it at about half a second per reading.
- You bake in big bowls or weigh straight onto sheet pans
- You step away mid-recipe and want your reading kept for 15 minutes
- You weigh raw meat and want a tray you can wash
- You want the scale most test kitchens agree on
Escali Primo Digital Scale
The Escali Primo has been Wirecutter's top kitchen scale since 2017. Laura Motley and Tyler Wells Lynch have run 23 scales through lab-weight tests over the years, and the Primo still reads in under a second. Its four-minute auto-off was the second-longest Wirecutter measured, and testers could finish a slow pour-over without the screen going dark.
- You care about accurate grams more than extra features
- Your drawers are already crowded
- You mostly weigh into small and medium bowls
- You measure in ounces and want 0.05 oz steps