Skip to main content
Ceiling Fans · Comparison

The Minka-Aire Light Wave 52-Inch Ceiling Fan meets
the Westinghouse Comet 52-Inch Ceiling Fan

The top Overall Score (90) in Consumer Reports' ceiling fan lab, with perfect marks for airflow and for noise at both speeds. We tested it head-to-head against the Westinghouse Comet 52-Inch Ceiling Fan across 6 key dimensions.

Minka-Aire Light Wave 52-inch ceiling fan in white, three-quarter view showing the downrod, canopy, three curved blades and integrated LED light on a white background
BEST

Minka-Aire Light Wave 52-Inch Ceiling Fan

“The top Overall Score (90) in Consumer Reports' ceiling fan lab, with perfect marks for airflow and for noise at both speeds”

$399MSRP
Our Score
85.3 / 100
Westinghouse Comet 52-inch ceiling fan in white with five white blades, downrod and frosted glass LED light fixture, shown at a three-quarter angle on a white background
VALUE

Westinghouse Comet 52-Inch Ceiling Fan

“One of only two fans Consumer Reports rated excellent and Popular Mechanics' Best Overall, for well under half the Light Wave's price”

Our Score
79.5 / 100
01

Head-to-Head Breakdown

Airflow
30% of score +
Minka-Aire
90
Westinghouse Lighting
88
Minka-Aire Light Wave 52-Inch Ceiling Fan

Full marks for airflow in Consumer Reports' anemometer tests, one of three fans in its top five to get them. Minka rates it at 4,453 CFM on high, more than the Comet or the Carnegie.

Westinghouse Comet 52-Inch Ceiling Fan

Full marks for airflow in Consumer Reports' lab, matching the Light Wave. Westinghouse rates it at 3,589 CFM, and Popular Mechanics says it suits rooms up to 400 square feet.

Quiet
20% of score +
Minka-Aire
92
Westinghouse Lighting
92
Minka-Aire Light Wave 52-Inch Ceiling Fan

Consumer Reports gave it 5 of 5 for noise at both high and low speed. Popular Mechanics passes along owner reports of a hum after installation that faded after a day of running.

Westinghouse Comet 52-Inch Ceiling Fan

Consumer Reports gave it 5 of 5 for noise at high and low speed, and Popular Mechanics calls it quiet even on high.

Controls
15% of score +
Minka-Aire
82
Westinghouse Lighting
50
Minka-Aire Light Wave 52-Inch Ceiling Fan

The included remote handles three speeds, the dimmer and reverse. Phone and voice control need a separate Bond bridge, per Popular Mechanics, and three speeds is half what the DC fans here offer.

Westinghouse Comet 52-Inch Ceiling Fan

Pull chains run the three speeds and the light. No remote comes in the box.

Install
15% of score +
Minka-Aire
72
Westinghouse Lighting
84
Minka-Aire Light Wave 52-Inch Ceiling Fan

A 6-inch downrod comes in the box, so taller ceilings need no extra parts, per Popular Mechanics. There is no flush option for low ceilings.

Westinghouse Comet 52-Inch Ceiling Fan

The combo mount hangs on a downrod or tight to the ceiling, which made it Top Ten Reviews' best low-profile fan.

Light
10% of score +
Minka-Aire
80
Westinghouse Lighting
60
Minka-Aire Light Wave 52-Inch Ceiling Fan

Integrated dimmable LED, rated at 20 watts by Minka and dimmed from the remote.

Westinghouse Comet 52-Inch Ceiling Fan

Integrated dimmable LED, but Popular Mechanics calls the light soft and possibly too dim for some rooms.

Trust
10% of score +
Minka-Aire
88
Westinghouse Lighting
86
Minka-Aire Light Wave 52-Inch Ceiling Fan

Consumer Reports' top Overall Score of 90 and Popular Mechanics' Best Wi-Fi-Enabled pick, from a long-running fan maker.

Westinghouse Comet 52-Inch Ceiling Fan

One of two fans Consumer Reports rated excellent (86) and Popular Mechanics' Best Overall. Westinghouse covers the motor for life and other parts for two years.

02

Strengths & Weaknesses

Minka-Aire Light Wave 52-Inch Ceiling Fan

+ Strengths
  • Consumer Reports' highest Overall Score (90), one of only two fans it rated excellent
  • Full CR marks for airflow and for noise at both high and low speed
  • Remote, dimmable LED and a 6-inch downrod all come in the box
− Weaknesses
  • Lists at $399, roughly double the next priciest fan in CR's test, per Hunker
  • Three speeds only, and app control needs a Bond bridge bought separately
  • Rated for dry indoor rooms only, so skip it for porches
Key flaw: Price is the catch.

Westinghouse Comet 52-Inch Ceiling Fan

+ Strengths
  • Scored 86 in Consumer Reports' lab, second only to the Light Wave
  • Full CR marks for airflow and for noise at high and low speed
  • Mounts flush or on a downrod, so low ceilings are no problem
− Weaknesses
  • Pull chains only, with no remote in the box
  • Popular Mechanics calls the light soft and possibly too dim
  • Top Ten Reviews marks it down for efficiency at 57 CFM per watt
Key flaw: Don't count on the Comet to light a room.
03

The Verdict

Our Bottom Line

Consumer Reports ran 52-inch ceiling fans from nine manufacturers through its lab, reading wind speed with an anemometer at nine spots around each fan on high and low, then measuring the noise from both the motor and the moving air. Only two fans earned excellent Overall Scores. The Minka-Aire Light Wave scored highest, at 90, with top marks for airflow and for noise at both speeds.

BEST
Minka-Aire Light Wave 52-Inch Ceiling Fan
Minka-Aire Light Wave 52-inch ceiling fan in white, three-quarter view showing the downrod, canopy, three curved blades and integrated LED light on a white background

Consumer Reports ran 52-inch ceiling fans from nine manufacturers through its lab, reading wind speed with an anemometer at nine spots around each fan on high and low, then measuring the noise from both the motor and the moving air. Only two fans earned excellent Overall Scores. The Minka-Aire Light Wave scored highest, at 90, with top marks for airflow and for noise at both speeds.

Best for:
  • You want the highest-scoring fan in Consumer Reports' lab
  • You'd rather change speed, light and direction from the couch
  • You like a three-blade modern look
  • You may add phone or voice control later with a Bond bridge
VALUE
Westinghouse Comet 52-Inch Ceiling Fan
Westinghouse Comet 52-inch ceiling fan in white with five white blades, downrod and frosted glass LED light fixture, shown at a three-quarter angle on a white background

Consumer Reports gave only one other fan an excellent Overall Score, and it was the Westinghouse Comet. It scored 86 and matched the Light Wave's perfect marks for airflow and for noise at both speeds. CR's approximate retail price for it was $140, against $360 for the Light Wave.

Best for:
  • You want lab-proven airflow and quiet for well under half the price
  • Your ceiling is low and the fan needs to mount flush
  • You leave the fan on a wall switch and rarely change speeds
  • You prefer a classic five-blade design
04

Specifications

Spec Minka-Aire Light Wave 52-Inch Ceiling Fan Westinghouse Comet 52-Inch Ceiling Fan
Blade Span 52 in 52 in
Airflow 4453 CFM 3589 CFM
Power (High) 67.5 W 63 W
Motor AC AC
Speeds 3 3
Control Handheld remote Pull chains
Light Dimmable integrated LED Dimmable integrated LED
Mounting Downrod (6 in. included) Flush or downrod
Rating Indoor, dry Indoor, dry
Warranty — Lifetime motor, 2-year parts
Read the full Ceiling Fans review
Menu