Skip to main content
Vegan Pizza · Comparison

The Daiya Meatless Supreme Pizza meets
the 365 by Whole Foods Market Vegan Ultimate Veggie Pizza

Tasting Table's best supreme of 2026 and Sporked's Best Supreme, loaded with Beyond Meat sausage on a gluten-free crust. We tested it head-to-head against the 365 by Whole Foods Market Vegan Ultimate Veggie Pizza across 6 key dimensions.

Daiya Dairy-Free Meatless Supreme thin-crust pizza box, front view, showing the 19.4 oz gluten-free pizza topped with sausage-style crumbles, peppers, red onion and mushrooms
BEST

Daiya Meatless Supreme Pizza

“Tasting Table's best supreme of 2026 and Sporked's Best Supreme, loaded with Beyond Meat sausage on a gluten-free crust”

Our Score
81.8 / 100
365 by Whole Foods Market Vegan Ultimate Veggie Thin Crust Pizza 13.7 oz box front, showing pizza slices topped with black olives, bell peppers, mushrooms and red onion
VALUE

365 by Whole Foods Market Vegan Ultimate Veggie Pizza

“Tasting Table's #3 of 8 at about $5.50, the one pizza its taster called appropriately priced”

Our Score
76.6 / 100
01

Head-to-Head Breakdown

Taste
30% of score +
Daiya Foods
86
Whole Foods Market
84
Daiya Meatless Supreme Pizza

Tasting Table's Samantha Maxwell called it "the best supreme I tried" and "way better than Amy's take on the dish," ranking it #4 of 8. Sporked gave it 9 out of 10.

365 by Whole Foods Market Vegan Ultimate Veggie Pizza

Ranked #3 of 8 by Tasting Table, one spot above Daiya's Supreme. Maxwell liked that it "feels sort of no-nonsense," with black olives that make it taste like a classic pizza.

Crust
20% of score +
Daiya Foods
64
Whole Foods Market
82
Daiya Meatless Supreme Pizza

The gluten-free crust is thin. Make It Dairy Free noticed it, and Tasting Table found Daiya's crusts soggier than it wanted across the line.

365 by Whole Foods Market Vegan Ultimate Veggie Pizza

A much thinner crust than the rest, which gave "a pleasant crunch, and slices that don't sag and droop." Maxwell warned that may not suit everyone.

Cheese
20% of score +
Daiya Foods
84
Whole Foods Market
70
Daiya Meatless Supreme Pizza

Daiya's shreds melt better than most: Sporked found Trader Joe's cheese didn't melt as well as Daiya's, though Make It Dairy Free thought Daiya used a little too much.

365 by Whole Foods Market Vegan Ultimate Veggie Pizza

Mozzarella-style pea milk shreds that no source singled out, good or bad.

Toppings
10% of score +
Daiya Foods
84
Whole Foods Market
70
Daiya Meatless Supreme Pizza

Maxwell "got a ton of toppings in every bite," with Beyond Meat crumbles that read as meat. The vegetables can turn soggy.

365 by Whole Foods Market Vegan Ultimate Veggie Pizza

Bell peppers, black olives, mushrooms and red onion, with no vegan meat.

Trust
10% of score +
Daiya Foods
90
Whole Foods Market
72
Daiya Meatless Supreme Pizza

Top four in all three tastings that included it: Tasting Table (#4 of 8), Sporked (9 out of 10) and Make It Dairy Free (Daiya #2 of 10). VegNews and VegOut both list Daiya too.

365 by Whole Foods Market Vegan Ultimate Veggie Pizza

Tasting Table's #3, and both VegNews and VegOut include it in their editors' picks, VegOut calling it budget-friendly.

Availability
10% of score +
Daiya Foods
90
Whole Foods Market
68
Daiya Meatless Supreme Pizza

Sold at Whole Foods, Target and Walmart according to Sporked and Make It Dairy Free, and on Amazon through Whole Foods.

365 by Whole Foods Market Vegan Ultimate Veggie Pizza

Whole Foods only, in stores or through Amazon.

02

Strengths & Weaknesses

Daiya Meatless Supreme Pizza

+ Strengths
  • "The best supreme I tried" in Tasting Table's October 2026 test, ahead of Amy's version
  • Placed top four in all three tastings that included it
  • Certified gluten-free and free of soy and dairy
− Weaknesses
  • The thin gluten-free crust can turn soggy, as can the vegetables
  • Make It Dairy Free found Daiya pizzas a little heavy on cheese
  • About $10 to $11 at Whole Foods, double the 365 pizza
Key flaw: The crust is the weak link.

365 by Whole Foods Market Vegan Ultimate Veggie Pizza

+ Strengths
  • About $5.50, which Tasting Table called the only appropriately priced pizza it tried
  • Ranked above Daiya's Supreme in Tasting Table's 2026 test
  • A thin, crunchy crust whose slices hold their shape
− Weaknesses
  • Only sold at Whole Foods and through its Amazon storefront
  • No vegan meat, just vegetables
  • The very thin crust won't please fans of a bready pizza
Key flaw: You can only buy it at Whole Foods, in store or through Amazon.
03

The Verdict

Our Bottom Line

Daiya's Meatless Supreme is the one pizza that placed in the top four of all three taste tests that included it. Tasting Table's Samantha Maxwell ranked it #4 of 8 dairy-free frozen pizzas in October 2026 and called it "the best supreme I tried" and "way better than Amy's take on the dish." Sporked gave it 9 out of 10 and its Best Supreme award, and Make It Dairy Free ranked Daiya's supreme and pepperoni pies second of the 10 brands it baked.

BEST
Daiya Meatless Supreme Pizza
Daiya Dairy-Free Meatless Supreme thin-crust pizza box, front view, showing the 19.4 oz gluten-free pizza topped with sausage-style crumbles, peppers, red onion and mushrooms

Daiya's Meatless Supreme is the one pizza that placed in the top four of all three taste tests that included it. Tasting Table's Samantha Maxwell ranked it #4 of 8 dairy-free frozen pizzas in October 2026 and called it "the best supreme I tried" and "way better than Amy's take on the dish." Sporked gave it 9 out of 10 and its Best Supreme award, and Make It Dairy Free ranked Daiya's supreme and pepperoni pies second of the 10 brands it baked.

Best for:
  • You want a loaded supreme with vegan sausage and vegetables
  • You need a pizza that's gluten-free as well as dairy-free
  • You shop at Target, Walmart or Whole Foods and want a pizza you can find anywhere
  • You care more about toppings and melt than about the crust
VALUE
365 by Whole Foods Market Vegan Ultimate Veggie Pizza
365 by Whole Foods Market Vegan Ultimate Veggie Thin Crust Pizza 13.7 oz box front, showing pizza slices topped with black olives, bell peppers, mushrooms and red onion

Whole Foods' 365 Vegan Ultimate Veggie Pizza cost Tasting Table $5.49, about half what Daiya charges, and it still ranked #3 of 8, one place above Daiya's Supreme. Maxwell said she didn't weigh price in her ranking but called it "the only one appropriately priced."

Best for:
  • You live near a Whole Foods and want a vegan pizza for about $5
  • You like a thin, crisp crust that holds up when you pick up a slice
  • You prefer a classic veggie pizza without fake meat
  • You want something cheap enough to keep a few in the freezer
04

Specifications

Spec Daiya Meatless Supreme Pizza 365 by Whole Foods Market Vegan Ultimate Veggie Pizza
Crust Thin gluten-free Thin, organic wheat
Weight 19.4 oz 13.7 oz
Protein 6g per 1/4 pizza 5g per 1/3 pizza
Gluten-Free Yes No
Cheese Daiya oat cream mozzarella shreds Pea milk mozzarella-style shreds
Certifications Non-GMO Project Verified, Certified Gluten-Free Non-GMO Project Verified, Vegan
Read the full Vegan Pizza review
Menu