Skip to main content
Vegan Jerky · Comparison

The Louisville Vegan Jerky Co. Smokey Carolina BBQ meets
the Primal Spirit Hickory Smoked Vegan Jerky

VegNews readers' Best Jerky in 2025 and 2026, with inventive flavors handmade in small batches in Kentucky. We tested it head-to-head against the Primal Spirit Hickory Smoked Vegan Jerky across 6 key dimensions.

Louisville Vegan Jerky Co. Smokey Carolina BBQ bag
BEST

Louisville Vegan Jerky Co. Smokey Carolina BBQ

“VegNews readers' Best Jerky in 2025 and 2026, with inventive flavors handmade in small batches in Kentucky”

$7.29MSRP
Our Score
79.2 / 100
Primal Spirit Hickory Smoked Vegan Jerky display box showing individual strips
VALUE

Primal Spirit Hickory Smoked Vegan Jerky

“Sporked's Best Smoky at 8.5/10, with 10 g of protein in a 1 oz strip for about $1.66”

$39.95MSRP
Our Score
80.9 / 100
01

Head-to-Head Breakdown

Flavor
30% of score +
Louisville Vegan Jerky Co.
92
Primal Spirit Foods
78
Louisville Vegan Jerky Co. Smokey Carolina BBQ

Rhett & Link ranked the Smokey Carolina BBQ first of six, and Tasting Table said it knocked it out of the park on flavor. Sporked gave Buffalo Dill 7.5/10.

Primal Spirit Hickory Smoked Vegan Jerky

Sporked scored Hickory Smoked 8.5/10 but Thai Peanut only 6.5, and Rhett & Link ranked Texas Barbecue last of six.

Texture
25% of score +
Louisville Vegan Jerky Co.
68
Primal Spirit Foods
82
Louisville Vegan Jerky Co. Smokey Carolina BBQ

Soft and pulled-pork-like. Tasting Table found small pieces with no pull, and it seemed softer than Make It Dairy Free's testers remembered.

Primal Spirit Hickory Smoked Vegan Jerky

Sporked praised a convincingly meaty texture, and Link called it very chewy in a good way.

Nutrition
15% of score +
Louisville Vegan Jerky Co.
62
Primal Spirit Foods
85
Louisville Vegan Jerky Co. Smokey Carolina BBQ

5 g of protein per ounce, 15 g per bag, with 7 g of sugar per serving.

Primal Spirit Hickory Smoked Vegan Jerky

10 g of protein in a 1 oz strip, double Louisville's per ounce.

Ingredients
10% of score +
Louisville Vegan Jerky Co.
82
Primal Spirit Foods
68
Louisville Vegan Jerky Co. Smokey Carolina BBQ

Non-GMO textured soy and tamari, certified vegan and gluten-free.

Primal Spirit Hickory Smoked Vegan Jerky

Isolated soy and wheat protein, Non-GMO Project Verified.

Availability
10% of score +
Louisville Vegan Jerky Co.
78
Primal Spirit Foods
92
Louisville Vegan Jerky Co. Smokey Carolina BBQ

Sold on its own site, on Amazon and at Albertsons-owned grocers, at $7.29 a bag from the maker.

Primal Spirit Hickory Smoked Vegan Jerky

About $1.66 a strip in a 24-pack, and easy to find in single-serve packs.

Trust
10% of score +
Louisville Vegan Jerky Co.
93
Primal Spirit Foods
82
Louisville Vegan Jerky Co. Smokey Carolina BBQ

VegNews readers voted it Best Jerky in 2025 and 2026, and it placed top three at Rhett & Link, Tasting Table and Make It Dairy Free.

Primal Spirit Hickory Smoked Vegan Jerky

Third for Best Jerky in the 2026 VegNews vote and Sporked's Best Smoky pick.

02

Strengths & Weaknesses

Louisville Vegan Jerky Co. Smokey Carolina BBQ

+ Strengths
  • VegNews readers' Best Jerky in both 2025 and 2026
  • Rhett & Link's #1 of six and Tasting Table's #2 of 13
  • Certified gluten-free, with flavors like Buffalo Dill and Perfect Pepperoni
− Weaknesses
  • Only 5 g of protein per ounce
  • Tasting Table found small pieces with no pull
  • 7 g of sugar per serving
Key flaw: Louisville lists a 3 oz bag at $7.

Primal Spirit Hickory Smoked Vegan Jerky

+ Strengths
  • Sporked's Best Smoky at 8.5/10
  • 10 g of protein per 1 oz strip
  • About $1.66 a strip in a 24-pack
− Weaknesses
  • Rhett & Link ranked its Texas Barbecue last of six
  • Flavor quality varies across the range
  • Contains wheat, so it's out for celiac buyers
Key flaw: Rhett & Link ranked Primal Spirit last of six, noting 'it smells not so great' for the Texas Barbecue variant.
03

The Verdict

Our Bottom Line

Primal Spirit edges Louisville on our weighted score because a 1 oz strip packs 10 g of protein, double Louisville's 5 g per ounce, and costs less per ounce. We still rank Louisville first because the taste tests do: VegNews readers voted it Best Jerky in 2025 and 2026, Rhett & Link put it first of six, and Tasting Table placed it second among 13 brands. Rhett & Link ranked Primal Spirit last.

BEST
Louisville Vegan Jerky Co. Smokey Carolina BBQ
Louisville Vegan Jerky Co. Smokey Carolina BBQ bag

Louisville Vegan Jerky Co. is the most consistent name across the reviews we weighed. VegNews readers voted it Best Jerky in both the 2025 and 2026 Veggie Awards. Rhett McLaughlin and Link Neal, tasting on Good Mythical Morning, ranked the Smokey Carolina BBQ #1 of six brands, with Rhett exclaiming, 'This has got a lot of flavor. WOW.' Tasting Table's Sara Klimek placed it #2 of 13 brands, and Make It Dairy Free put it in its top three. Happy Happy Vegan and The Vegan Skillet both ranked it first in their roundups.

Best for:
  • You care about creative, restaurant-quality flavors beyond standard BBQ and teriyaki
  • You want 15g of protein per bag from a clean ingredient list with no artificial additives
  • You're buying jerky as a premium snack or gift, not an everyday gas-station grab
  • You prefer softer, moister jerky texture over tough leather-style chew
  • Supporting small-batch, family-run production matters to your purchasing decisions
VALUE
Primal Spirit Hickory Smoked Vegan Jerky
Primal Spirit Hickory Smoked Vegan Jerky display box showing individual strips

Primal Spirit shows up across the field, from Sporked's tasting to Good Mythical Morning to the VegNews awards, where readers voted it third for Best Jerky in 2026. Sporked's Justine Sterling scored the Hickory Smoked flavor 8.5/10, praising a 'convincingly meaty texture' and a smoke flavor that 'fools your brain into thinking you're tasting meat.'

Best for:
  • You want to try vegan jerky without risking $7 on a bag you might not like
  • You need grab-and-go snacks from convenience stores and gas stations, not specialty retailers
  • Budget matters and you buy jerky frequently for road trips, gym bags, or lunchboxes
  • You prefer the meaty, chewy texture of traditional jerky over softer pulled-pork styles
  • You don't have celiac disease or wheat sensitivity (seitan is a key ingredient)
04

Specifications

Spec Louisville Vegan Jerky Co. Smokey Carolina BBQ Primal Spirit Hickory Smoked Vegan Jerky
Base Non-GMO Textured Soy Non-GMO Soy & Wheat Protein
Protein 15 g/bag —
Size 3 oz 1 oz
Gluten-Free Yes —
Non-GMO Yes Yes
Allergens Soy Soy, Wheat
Protein — 10 g/strip
Format — Single-Serve Strip
Read the full Vegan Jerky review
Menu