The JUST Egg Plant-Based Egg meets
the Bob's Red Mill Gluten Free Egg Replacer
The 2026 VegNews Best Egg winner, a mung bean liquid that scrambles fluffy and bakes too. We tested it head-to-head against the Bob's Red Mill Gluten Free Egg Replacer across 6 key dimensions.
JUST Egg Plant-Based Egg
“The 2026 VegNews Best Egg winner, a mung bean liquid that scrambles fluffy and bakes too”
Bob's Red Mill Gluten Free Egg Replacer
“A four-ingredient baking powder that replaces 34 eggs a bag, and the 2026 VegNews runner-up for Best Egg”
Head-to-Head Breakdown
Strengths & Weaknesses
JUST Egg Plant-Based Egg
- Ranked #1 of six by Tasting Table and 9/10 at both Sporked and Green Queen
- Won Best Egg in the 2026 VegNews Veggie Awards
- Pours straight from the carton, with 3 tablespoons replacing one egg
- Tasting Table's reviewer could still taste the mung beans
- Refrigerated only, with no shelf-stable version
- Sticks to the pan unless you cook it in oil
Bob's Red Mill Gluten Free Egg Replacer
- Replaces 34 eggs per 12 oz bag
- Second only to JUST Egg in the 2026 VegNews Veggie Awards' Best Egg category
- Shelf-stable, gluten-free and made from four ingredients
- Baking only, so you can't scramble it or make an omelet
- No protein, so it binds without adding nutrition
- Gives less lift than Ener-G in sponge and angel food cakes
The Verdict
Our Bottom Line
JUST Egg took the #1 spot when Tasting Table's Sierra Winters cooked six commercial egg replacers as plain scrambles. Winters said her scramble 'was fluffy and had a light mouthfeel with no trace of gumminess,' and credited it with a 'subtle cheesy flavor.' Green Queen's Alessandra Franco scored it 9/10 after testing nine products and called it the plant-based egg to beat for mouthfeel, versatility and ease of preparation. Newer verdicts agree: Sporked rated the scramble 9/10, and it won Best Egg in the 2026 VegNews Veggie Awards.
JUST Egg Plant-Based Egg
JUST Egg took the #1 spot when Tasting Table's Sierra Winters cooked six commercial egg replacers as plain scrambles. Winters said her scramble 'was fluffy and had a light mouthfeel with no trace of gumminess,' and credited it with a 'subtle cheesy flavor.' Green Queen's Alessandra Franco scored it 9/10 after testing nine products and called it the plant-based egg to beat for mouthfeel, versatility and ease of preparation. Newer verdicts agree: Sporked rated the scramble 9/10, and it won Best Egg in the 2026 VegNews Veggie Awards.
- You eat scrambled eggs, omelets, or egg-based breakfasts regularly and want a convincing plant-based replacement
- You want a single product that handles both savory cooking and baking without switching between formats
- You have access to a standard grocery store (Walmart, Target, Kroger) and want something easy to find
- You care most about taste and will spend a little more per carton for the closest thing to real eggs
Bob's Red Mill Gluten Free Egg Replacer
Bob's Red Mill Egg Replacer costs just pennies per egg equivalent. A single bag replaces 34 eggs. Bakers who go through eggs by the dozen will see the difference on their grocery bill.
- You bake often and need a reliable, flavorless egg substitute that won't change the taste of your recipes
- Budget is a priority, and a much lower cost per egg than JUST Egg matters over time
- You have dietary restrictions beyond veganism (gluten-free, soy-free, grain-free) and need a clean-label product
- You want shelf-stable pantry storage instead of taking up fridge space with a liquid product