Skip to main content
Vegan Egg Replacers · Comparison

The JUST Egg Plant-Based Egg meets
the Bob's Red Mill Gluten Free Egg Replacer

The 2026 VegNews Best Egg winner, a mung bean liquid that scrambles fluffy and bakes too. We tested it head-to-head against the Bob's Red Mill Gluten Free Egg Replacer across 6 key dimensions.

JUST Egg plant-based carton 16oz front packaging on white background
BEST

JUST Egg Plant-Based Egg

“The 2026 VegNews Best Egg winner, a mung bean liquid that scrambles fluffy and bakes too”

Our Score
89.6 / 100
Bob's Red Mill Gluten Free Vegan Egg Replacer 12oz bag front view
VALUE

Bob's Red Mill Gluten Free Egg Replacer

“A four-ingredient baking powder that replaces 34 eggs a bag, and the 2026 VegNews runner-up for Best Egg”

Our Score
72.6 / 100
01

Head-to-Head Breakdown

Taste
25% of score +
Eat Just
90
Bob's Red Mill
55
JUST Egg Plant-Based Egg

Tasting Table ranked it #1 of six and praised its subtle cheesy flavor, Green Queen gave it Best Taste at 9/10, and Sporked scored the scramble 9/10. The Takeout's tester preferred Hodo's flavor.

Bob's Red Mill Gluten Free Egg Replacer

Neutral in baked goods, but it has no egg flavor of its own and can't stand in for eggs on the plate.

Versatility
25% of score +
Eat Just
92
Bob's Red Mill
62
JUST Egg Plant-Based Egg

Scrambles, omelets, quiche and baking from one carton. Green Queen called it the plant-based egg to beat on versatility.

Bob's Red Mill Gluten Free Egg Replacer

Works in cookies, brownies, muffins and quick breads. It can't be scrambled or made into an omelet.

Texture
20% of score +
Eat Just
88
Bob's Red Mill
78
JUST Egg Plant-Based Egg

Tasting Table's scramble was fluffy with a light mouthfeel and no trace of gumminess.

Bob's Red Mill Gluten Free Egg Replacer

Potato starch, tapioca and psyllium bind well, and Gretchen's Vegan Bakery prefers it to Ener-G for consistency. It gives less lift in airy cakes.

Ease of Use
10% of score +
Eat Just
82
Bob's Red Mill
90
JUST Egg Plant-Based Egg

Pours straight from the carton at 3 tablespoons per egg, but Tasting Table notes it takes a little longer to cook, and it sticks without oil.

Bob's Red Mill Gluten Free Egg Replacer

Whisk a tablespoon of powder with water and it's ready to use.

Availability
10% of score +
Eat Just
90
Bob's Red Mill
95
JUST Egg Plant-Based Egg

Sold at Walmart, Target, Kroger and Whole Foods in a 16 oz carton, and on Amazon.

Bob's Red Mill Gluten Free Egg Replacer

Shelf-stable and stocked by most US grocers, plus Amazon.

Trust
10% of score +
Eat Just
93
Bob's Red Mill
92
JUST Egg Plant-Based Egg

Best Egg in the 2026 VegNews Veggie Awards, Food Network's Best All-Purpose pick and Sporked's Best of the Best.

Bob's Red Mill Gluten Free Egg Replacer

Runner-up to JUST Egg for Best Egg in the 2026 VegNews Veggie Awards, and Mashed ranks commercial replacers like it first among 16 egg substitutes.

02

Strengths & Weaknesses

JUST Egg Plant-Based Egg

+ Strengths
  • Ranked #1 of six by Tasting Table and 9/10 at both Sporked and Green Queen
  • Won Best Egg in the 2026 VegNews Veggie Awards
  • Pours straight from the carton, with 3 tablespoons replacing one egg
− Weaknesses
  • Tasting Table's reviewer could still taste the mung beans
  • Refrigerated only, with no shelf-stable version
  • Sticks to the pan unless you cook it in oil
Key flaw: Mung bean protein leaves a faint legume aftertaste that some tasters notice, especially in lightly seasoned preparations.

Bob's Red Mill Gluten Free Egg Replacer

+ Strengths
  • Replaces 34 eggs per 12 oz bag
  • Second only to JUST Egg in the 2026 VegNews Veggie Awards' Best Egg category
  • Shelf-stable, gluten-free and made from four ingredients
− Weaknesses
  • Baking only, so you can't scramble it or make an omelet
  • No protein, so it binds without adding nutrition
  • Gives less lift than Ener-G in sponge and angel food cakes
Key flaw: Bob's Red Mill is a baking product, full stop.
03

The Verdict

Our Bottom Line

JUST Egg took the #1 spot when Tasting Table's Sierra Winters cooked six commercial egg replacers as plain scrambles. Winters said her scramble 'was fluffy and had a light mouthfeel with no trace of gumminess,' and credited it with a 'subtle cheesy flavor.' Green Queen's Alessandra Franco scored it 9/10 after testing nine products and called it the plant-based egg to beat for mouthfeel, versatility and ease of preparation. Newer verdicts agree: Sporked rated the scramble 9/10, and it won Best Egg in the 2026 VegNews Veggie Awards.

BEST
JUST Egg Plant-Based Egg
JUST Egg plant-based carton 16oz front packaging on white background

JUST Egg took the #1 spot when Tasting Table's Sierra Winters cooked six commercial egg replacers as plain scrambles. Winters said her scramble 'was fluffy and had a light mouthfeel with no trace of gumminess,' and credited it with a 'subtle cheesy flavor.' Green Queen's Alessandra Franco scored it 9/10 after testing nine products and called it the plant-based egg to beat for mouthfeel, versatility and ease of preparation. Newer verdicts agree: Sporked rated the scramble 9/10, and it won Best Egg in the 2026 VegNews Veggie Awards.

Best for:
  • You eat scrambled eggs, omelets, or egg-based breakfasts regularly and want a convincing plant-based replacement
  • You want a single product that handles both savory cooking and baking without switching between formats
  • You have access to a standard grocery store (Walmart, Target, Kroger) and want something easy to find
  • You care most about taste and will spend a little more per carton for the closest thing to real eggs
VALUE
Bob's Red Mill Gluten Free Egg Replacer
Bob's Red Mill Gluten Free Vegan Egg Replacer 12oz bag front view

Bob's Red Mill Egg Replacer costs just pennies per egg equivalent. A single bag replaces 34 eggs. Bakers who go through eggs by the dozen will see the difference on their grocery bill.

Best for:
  • You bake often and need a reliable, flavorless egg substitute that won't change the taste of your recipes
  • Budget is a priority, and a much lower cost per egg than JUST Egg matters over time
  • You have dietary restrictions beyond veganism (gluten-free, soy-free, grain-free) and need a clean-label product
  • You want shelf-stable pantry storage instead of taking up fridge space with a liquid product
04

Specifications

Spec JUST Egg Plant-Based Egg Bob's Red Mill Gluten Free Egg Replacer
Base Mung Bean Protein Potato Starch, Tapioca Flour, Psyllium Husk
Format Liquid (Pourable) Powder (Mix with Water)
Size 16 fl oz 12 oz
Protein 5g per serving 0g per serving
Servings 10 eggs 34 eggs
Storage Refrigerated Shelf-stable
Certifications Non-GMO, Cholesterol-Free Gluten Free, Vegan, Non-GMO, Kosher
Allergens Egg-free, dairy-free, soy-free None (free of top 14 allergens)
Read the full Vegan Egg Replacers review
Menu