The MyForest Foods MyBacon Original Recipe meets
the Lightlife Smart Bacon
Mycelium strips that crisp in their own coconut oil, ranked first by Sporked and Chowhound. We tested it head-to-head against the Lightlife Smart Bacon across 6 key dimensions.
MyForest Foods MyBacon Original Recipe
“Mycelium strips that crisp in their own coconut oil, ranked first by Sporked and Chowhound”
Lightlife Smart Bacon
“The reader-vote favorite you can find in most supermarket produce coolers”
Head-to-Head Breakdown
Strengths & Weaknesses
MyForest Foods MyBacon Original Recipe
- Ranked first by Sporked (9.5/10) and by Chowhound's 8-brand pan-fry test, where Audrey Farnsworth, a self-described mushroom disliker, said you can't taste any mushrooms
- Each pack includes coconut oil that melts into the pan, so the strips fry in their own fat and leave grease behind, the detail Sporked singled out
- Five ingredients with no wheat or soy, and certified Plant Based by NSF, Keto Certified and OU Kosher
- Texture varies strip to strip: Sporked likened it to Canadian bacon, and Vegan in the Freezer found the thick sections stayed chewy and a bit rubbery
- The current label lists 420 mg sodium and only 3 g protein per 2-slice serving
- Skillet-only cooking that takes 8 minutes or more, and it is hard to find outside Whole Foods, Erewhon and online grocers
Lightlife Smart Bacon
- VegNews readers voted it Best Bacon in both 2025 and 2026, ahead of Upton's Naturals and MyForest Foods
- Stocked at Kroger, Albertsons, ShopRite, Whole Foods and Sprouts, per Tasting Table and retailer listings, so you rarely need to order online
- Cooks in about 3 minutes in a skillet or 5 in the oven, at 40 calories and 5 g protein per 2-slice serving
- Hands-on tests put it near the bottom: 6th of 8 at Chowhound and 6th of 7 at Tasting Table
- Tasting Table found it dry with no grease, closer to bacon bits than strips, and Chowhound compared the taste to turkey bacon
- Contains wheat and soy, so it is out for gluten-free or soy-free diets
The Verdict
Our Bottom Line
MyForest Foods MyBacon won because it solved the hardest problem in vegan bacon: making something that actually tastes like bacon without relying on liquid smoke dumped onto soy protein. The mycelium base (grown from mushroom roots, not assembled from isolates) produces a savory, smoky flavor that Sporked's Ariana Losch scored 9.5/10, calling it 'one of the tastiest vegan foods I've tried during my time at Sporked.' Chowhound's Audrey Farnsworth put it #1 out of 8 brands, calling it 'smokey, delicious' and noting 'you can't taste any mushrooms here.'
MyForest Foods MyBacon Original Recipe
MyForest Foods MyBacon won because it solved the hardest problem in vegan bacon: making something that actually tastes like bacon without relying on liquid smoke dumped onto soy protein. The mycelium base (grown from mushroom roots, not assembled from isolates) produces a savory, smoky flavor that Sporked's Ariana Losch scored 9.5/10, calling it 'one of the tastiest vegan foods I've tried during my time at Sporked.' Chowhound's Audrey Farnsworth put it #1 out of 8 brands, calling it 'smokey, delicious' and noting 'you can't taste any mushrooms here.'
- Bacon flavor matters more to you than price or convenience
- You're gluten-free or soy-sensitive and need a vegan bacon that avoids both major allergen categories
- You already shop at Whole Foods or a natural grocer and will spend more for a specialty strip
- You want the coconut oil sizzle and pan grease that makes cooking vegan bacon actually feel like cooking bacon
Lightlife Smart Bacon
Lightlife Smart Bacon takes the value spot on reach and price. It sits in more supermarket chains than any other pick here, and it costs roughly a third less per ounce than MyBacon. Make It Dairy Free found it the most easily available vegan bacon in its test, and per ounce it costs roughly a third less than MyBacon or Thrilling Foods.
- You shop at mainstream groceries and need a vegan bacon you can find without planning ahead or ordering online
- Budget matters and you're buying vegan bacon regularly, not as a one-time experiment
- You're new to vegan bacon and want the safest, most widely-validated first pick (VegNews readers voted it Best Bacon in 2025 and 2026)
- You mainly use bacon as a crispy topping for BLTs, salads, and sandwiches rather than as a standalone protein