The Bumkins Silicone Grip Dish meets
the Munchkin Splash Plate & Bowl Set
Suction so strong your toddler will give up trying to lift it. We tested it head-to-head against the Munchkin Splash Plate & Bowl Set ($11.99) across 6 key dimensions.
Bumkins Silicone Grip Dish
“Suction so strong your toddler will give up trying to lift it”
Munchkin Splash Plate & Bowl Set
“Four durable pieces for the price of one premium plate”
Head-to-Head Breakdown
Strengths & Weaknesses
Bumkins Silicone Grip Dish
- Strongest suction of any plate tested by Reviewed.com; stayed stuck on glass, wood, quartz, and crumb-covered surfaces
- 100% platinum-cured silicone with zero BPA, PVC, lead, or phthalates, confirmed by Little Loving Life's third-party testing research
- Oven, microwave, freezer, and dishwasher safe, available in 12+ colors
- Silicone absorbs soapy taste and smell if left soaking, per The Bump and Little Loving Life
- Dividers can crack after extended heavy use according to The Bump's long-term testing
- BabyGearLab scored it just 52/100, noting it may require specific dish soap to avoid residue
Munchkin Splash Plate & Bowl Set
- Four-piece set (2 plates + 2 bowls) for under $16, the lowest per-piece cost of any option reviewed
- Fully microwave and dishwasher safe with zero maintenance, unlike bamboo or stainless steel alternatives
- Deep sides on both plates and bowls reduce food spillage, praised by Motherly for mess control
- No suction at all, just anti-skid rubber on the bottom, so a determined toddler can still toss them
- BabyGearLab gave it the lowest eco-health score (46/100 overall) due to plastic material concerns
- Plastic scratches easily with metal utensils per BabyGearLab, and surfaces show wear after months of dishwasher use
The Verdict
Our Bottom Line
The Bumkins Silicone Grip Dish showed up in five of the seven sources we analyzed, and two of the most rigorous hands-on testers ranked it first. Rachel Murphy at Reviewed.com spent a month testing 12 suction plates across glass, wood, quartz, and plastic high chair trays. Her toddler could not lift the Bumkins from any surface. The mom behind Little Loving Life confirmed the same result after months of daily use with three children.
Bumkins Silicone Grip Dish
The Bumkins Silicone Grip Dish showed up in five of the seven sources we analyzed, and two of the most rigorous hands-on testers ranked it first. Rachel Murphy at Reviewed.com spent a month testing 12 suction plates across glass, wood, quartz, and plastic high chair trays. Her toddler could not lift the Bumkins from any surface. The mom behind Little Loving Life confirmed the same result after months of daily use with three children.
- Parents of toddlers in the active throwing phase (10-24 months) who need dishes that actually stay on the table
- Families who microwave food directly on the plate and want a material rated safe for heating
- Parents who want one high-quality plate per child rather than a drawer full of cheap sets
- Anyone concerned about material safety who wants to stay below the $25 price point of stainless steel options
- Daycare providers who need dishwasher-proof plates that survive rough handling from multiple children
Munchkin Splash Plate & Bowl Set
The Munchkin Splash Plate & Bowl Set gives you four pieces, two divided plates and two bowls, for around $16. That is $4 per piece. A single Bumkins plate costs $10. The math is simple.
- Budget-conscious families outfitting a full feeding station (plates and bowls) for under $20
- Parents of older toddlers (2+) who have mostly stopped throwing dishes
- Families who want microwave and dishwasher convenience with zero maintenance requirements
- Parents who need backup sets for grandparents' houses, daycare, or travel without spending premium prices
- Anyone who prioritizes practicality over material purity and just wants dishes that work