The TOTO Washlet S2 meets
the Tushy Classic 3.0
CNN's best bidet seat after 35 tested, with what its reviewer called the most comfortable stream by a good margin.. We tested it head-to-head against the Tushy Classic 3.0 across 6 key dimensions.
TOTO Washlet S2
“CNN's best bidet seat after 35 tested, with what its reviewer called the most comfortable stream by a good margin.”
Tushy Classic 3.0
“The $129 attachment that CNN picked over seats costing three times more”
Head-to-Head Breakdown
Strengths & Weaknesses
TOTO Washlet S2
- CNN's Best Bidet Seat after testing 35 models over nearly four years
- Wirecutter's runner-up for its heated seat, instant warm water and comfortable sprays
- Costs about $180 less than the TOTO S5 for the same core wash
- No remote, so every setting lives on the side panel
- Wirecutter notes there are no programmable user settings
- Needs a grounded outlet within reach of the toilet
Tushy Classic 3.0
- CNN Underscored ranked it #1 overall after testing 35 bidets because the adjustable nozzle delivers the most comfortable attachment spray on the market
- Zero electricity required: installs in 10 minutes using only your toilet's existing water supply, fitting both elongated and round bowls
- Yahoo Tested reviewer reported 5+ years of continuous use with no failures, proving the simple mechanical design ages well
- Cold water only, with no heated seat or dryer, which means winter mornings in cold climates are a bracing experience
- Yahoo Tested flagged the plastic control panel as 'flimsy' looking, a visual letdown at $129 even if it holds up functionally
- CNN's Burkhardt noted that upgrading to warm water requires the separate Tushy Ace, which costs significantly more
The Verdict
Our Bottom Line
Kai Burkhardt at CNN Underscored has installed and lived with 35 bidets over nearly four years, and the TOTO Washlet S2 is the seat he recommends. His verdict was blunt: it has the most comfortable stream of any bidet he has tested by a good margin. Wirecutter's Doug Mahoney, who has tested almost 40 seats since 2016, ranked it second only to the pricier TOTO S5.
TOTO Washlet S2
Kai Burkhardt at CNN Underscored has installed and lived with 35 bidets over nearly four years, and the TOTO Washlet S2 is the seat he recommends. His verdict was blunt: it has the most comfortable stream of any bidet he has tested by a good margin. Wirecutter's Doug Mahoney, who has tested almost 40 seats since 2016, ranked it second only to the pricier TOTO S5.
- Anyone who wants the most comfortable spray at a mainstream price
- Bidet owners ready to upgrade from a cold-water attachment
- Buyers who prefer simple side controls to a remote that can go missing
- Homes with a grounded outlet near the toilet
Tushy Classic 3.0
The Tushy Classic 3.0 earned the Best Value spot because CNN Underscored's Kai Burkhardt ranked it #1 overall after testing 35 bidets, full-featured electric seats included. At $129 with no electricity required, it delivers what Burkhardt called 'the most comfortable stream by far among attachments,' with an adjustable nozzle that makes precise targeting easier than competing attachments.
- First-time bidet users who want to try one for about $110
- Renters who cannot add an outlet or modify the bathroom
- Anyone with a mild climate who is comfortable with cold water
- Buyers who want a ten-minute install with no electrician